I love this chart. I've been using it since this came out and it has added SO MUCH to literally every single campaign and session. Without it I think 5e would have been very different for my players and myself. A must get.

This document has become a staple in every one of my games. I love the randomness of it. It did help my players defeat an Atropal in one hit becasuse of the instant kill effect. I like the idea that no matter how powerful someone is they can be felled in one hit.....but so can you!

These were much needed for me as I've always felt standard Crit and Fail rules weren't juicy enough. Can't believe it's free, you should definitely download now and bring some memorable moments to all those 20s and 1s.

This adds a huge amount of extra flavour to any crit. I love it!

As a DM this does add some fun to the all important dice rolls

I started using this to give some depth to combat results on a critical hit or miss, and it doesn't disappoint. It creates interesting, emergent situations for the players to face, especially on the critical miss side.

Solid effort here with quite creative outcomes. Well balanced in terms of the probablity of each event occurring in relation to the outcome severity. Happy to see both charts formatted on one page to give us some options for viewing/printing. Would like to see some variation for melee/ranged/spell attacks, but this chart will certainly provide some additional flair to your campaign!

Thanks. My adventurers are glad to have something beyond the normal critical fail. This table has them fearing 1 rolls more than usual.

I really like these charts!

There are interesting things that a hit can make happen and bad yet great fumbles that can occur.

Example; the butterfingers fumble result!

Butterfingers. Disarmed. Disadvantage on next attack roll.

Great!

EDIT: I made these charts into a rollable table on roll20 if anyone wants to use them, all the work is done!

Here's the Link

I love these charts, but more importantly my players do. The amount of excitement they get when they roll a Natural 20 is siginificantly amplified when it's followed with "ok, roll % dice." I've been usin these since they first released, so I thought it was time to drop a review here and let you know that I went a little deeper on my thoughts on the tables in my weekly DMs Guild spotlight video, found here: http://www.nerdimmersion.com/dd-5e-dms-guild-spotlight-critical-hitfumble-tables/

Better than the other charts I have downloaded! These can get pretty interesting! Fun Times ahead for my players. Muhahaha

Really well done. I'm not going to nit pick the formatting, it's fine if not spectacular, but the charts are a really solid effort. I'll probably use this in my campaign. I really like it.

Well done, I really like the charts. I have implemented in my game and they provide excitement for everyone although the players are not keen to be on the receiving end of crits by foes. I have an idea for them that I would like to discuss with you but I am not sure the best way to contact you.

Bill

A very handy list of crit/fumble tables that are easy to reference from a tablet or print to insert into a customizable DM screen. Not a fan of the cover art, but it does not detract from the awesomeness of the crit descriptions. Great fan addition to 5-e. Would be awesome to creat an app for this like the Pathfinder one.

Old school style of "oh you rolled well/poorly? let's have some fun." A bit unpredictable which I dig, random enough to make for frantic and chaotic combat. Will guarentee for excitement beyond the regular excitement of a natural 20 or a natural 1. I'd definitely use it in my games. If you're looking for a little bit of flavor added to your crits, this isn't the product for you but if you want game changing events to occur each critical, then this table is fantastic for that.